Shelly,
An oral surgeon pulled my tooth too and that is exactly how he was. In and out. But then again, I didn't want to hang around there any longer than necessary so it was fine with me! You WANT an oral surgeon to pull the tooth because that is what they do all day long, they're good at it, and they won't run into any problems. Ask for a Xanax (or similar anti anxiety med) to help get you to your appointment and in the chair, and ask for niterous gas to help you stay in the chair. That stuff had me half asleep and seriously, as they were talking to me (and trying to tell me my tooth was out) I was almost annoyed because I was so busy being relaxed! True story. I think I sat in the chair 15 minutes with the shots and waiting to get numb and an additional 4 minutes from start to finish when he pulled the tooth. Then they put gauze in my cheek, gave me a few prescriptions and a piece of paper with home care instructions and I was out of there. I know it's easy for me to say this now, but please try not to prolong this and put yourself through too much agony--you will kick yourself later for it. It really isn't that big of a deal. You're going to be fine, I promise.